08 16 1995 Council Minutes
..
-rD CORPOItAIfIOR OJ' ~ 'IODSBIP OJ' oaQ-1IBDON'lB
COUNCIL KBftING
WIIDlfB8DAY, AOGOS" 11, lttS . ':00 P.K. - COUNCIL CDIIB1IR8
ftD'lY-SBVBNTR KBftING l't4-1't' COUNCIL
council met this evening
present:
@ 7:00 p.m. with the following members
e
Mayor Ian Beard
Deputy Mayor Murray Martin
Councillor Walter Dickie
Councillor Neil Craig
Councillor Ron Sommers
Councillor Don Bell
Absent:
Councillor Larry Cotton
staff Present:
Gary cunnington, CAO, Jennifer
Zieleniewski, Treasurer, Mark
stagg, Planner, Paul Eenhoorn, Fire
Chief, Debbie Mooney, Tax Clerk.
Also Present Was:
Ed Murphy, Don Lamont, Alastair
Crawford, Bonnie McPhee, Valerie
Hamilton, Helen Bell, Shirley
Woodrow, Thelma Halfacre, Margaret
williams, Rob Rattray, Trevor
Graham, victor Koby, Jack
Bridgeman, Lloyd Leigh, Fern
Gilchrist, Bonnie Hill.
Mayor Ian Beard assumed the chair and called the meeting to
order, followed by prayer.
1. "DISCLOSURE OP PECUNIARY INTEREST AND THE GENERAL NATURE
THEREOF. - IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE ACT"
Councillor Don Bell declared a pecuniary interest with agenda item
7 (p) Livestock Valuer Report for calf killed. The nature being
Councillor Bell is the owner of the livestock killed by wolves.
Councillor Bell left the room for the discussion and did not
participate or vote on the resolution.
2. DEPUTATIONS:
(a) 7:30 p.m.
Mr. Sam Domenilli, Mr. Don Green and
Mr. Roger Husband, Ministry of
Revenue, Simcoe County Assessment
Office addressed Council concerning
County wide reassessment. Mr.
Domenilli provided brief history as
to the evolvement of the program
which started with a resolution from
County Council to prepare tax Impact
Study using 1992 market values.
There are two options available
being by "Full Market Value" or
"Factored". The 1992 values would
be used for implementation in 1996,
and updated every 4 years. County-
wide would see the same County and
education taxes paid on properties
having the same market values. The
local mill rates are applied by each
municipality. This provides a more
e
2. DEPUTATIONS CONTINUED:
e
(b) 9:00 p.m.
Tenderer
e
Arnott Construction Limited
- 2 -
"fair" approach and the complex
apportionment procedures would be
eliminated.
Mr. Husband explained the difference
between the two options, being that
Full Market Value would see tax
shifts occur among all property
classes, as well as within classes.
Factored by Property Class corrects
assessment and tax inequities within
each property class (residential and
farm, mUlti-residential, commercial,
industrial, pipelines) throughout
the County, but does not resol ve
inequi ty among classes. Both
options and the tax impacts
completed, include both the cities
of Barrie and Orillia as
participating. If either or both
opt not to be involved, new tax
impact studies will need to be done
taking approximately 6 weeks. Each
municipality will vote on whether
they want County-wide reassessment
and their preferred method. A
majority of the municipalities will
be needed prior to a majority of
County Council authorizing its
implementation. I
Mr. Husband distributed the Impact I
Studies on both methods and went I
through the documents with councilll
explaining the information containedl
therein. II
II
f'
In the event that county-widell
reassessment does proceed, theli
Ministry will send out newtl
assessment notices, host open houses[
in the Township and defend anYI
subsequent appeals. I
i
Mr. Paul Eenhoorn, Fire Chief I wasil
present to open tenders for thell
construction of the 4th Line].
Watermain to service the new Firell
station Headquarters in Horseshoell
Valley . Results as follows: II
11
I;
Amount
$114,169.00
$105,059.56
$104,940.25
$ 96,001.47
$ 93,048.00
$ 89,655.30
$ 89,123.00
$112,395.27
!:
II
II
Cascone Construction Limited
Bill Strudwick Construction Ltd.
Hulst Town Contracting Ltd.
(asphalt cut)
Kulson Kontracting & Management
(asphalt cut)
Midway Mechanical Inc.
North Rock Group Ltd.
(asphalt cut)
$ 95,200.99
$ 90,806.00
- 3 -
2. DEPUTATIONS CONTINUED:
(c) 9:20 p.m.
Mr. Charlie Softly, owner of Lot 92,
Plan 780, Eight Mile Point spoke to
Council concerning their fence at
driveway entrance encroaching on the
Township Road Allowance and possible
obstruction of vision from
neighbouring driveway onto roadway.
Mr. Softly provided in detail, the
existing situation and used diagrams
and pictures to aid in his
presentation. council had recently
requested that a portion of the
fence be removed, however a
compromised proposal for lowering
the South end was put forward.
e
General discussion also took place
respecting similar encroachments in
the area and the possibility of
relocating the road allowance (not
physically) to alleviate the
encumbrances.
3. CONSENT AGENDA CORRESPONDENCE:
(a) City of Barrie, Notice of Public Meeting re: Georgian Glen
Developments Ltd. - West side of penetanguishene Rd. between
Georgian Dr. & Hickling Trail.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
(b) city of Barrie, Notice of Public Meeting re: G.V. Dunsmore
Farms Ltd. - West side of Penetanguishene Rd. between Georgian
Dr. & Hickling Trail.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
(c) Nottawasaga Valley Conservation Authority, copy of
correspondence to City of Barrie re: Proposed Zoning By-law
Amendments - lands within the Georgian Drive Secondary Plan
Area, City of Barrie.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
(d) Association of Municipalities of Ontario, correspondence re:
Summary of Provincial Spending cuts.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
(e) Association of Municipalities of Ontario, correspondence re:
AMO and OGRA Secure Further Details on Transportation Cuts.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
e
(f) Aird & Berlis, Barristers & Solicitors, correspondence re:
Township of Oro-Medonte / B.A.F.M.A. Claim.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
(g) Doug Herbert, Lamont Beach Residents
correspondence re: Letter of Appreciation.
Recommendation: Receive and file.
Association,
(h) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 ewe killed by
wolves, ewe owned by David Anderson, Lot 10, Conc. 14,
(Orillia).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized to
make compensation to David Anderson in the amount of $200.00.
- 4 -
3. CONSENT AGENDA CORRESPONDENCE CONTINUED:
(i) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 lamb killed
wolves, lamb owned by David Anderson, Lot 10, Conc. 14,
(Orillia).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to David Anderson in the amount of $125.00.
e
(j) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 ewe killed
wolves, ewe owned by David Anderson, Lot 10, Conc. 14,
(Orillia).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to David Anderson in the amount of $200.00.
(k) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 2 lambs killed
wolves, lambs owned by David Anderson, Lot 10, Conc. 14,
(Orillia).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to David Anderson in the amount of $250.00.
(I) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 lamb killed
wolves, lamb owned by David Anderson, Lot 10, Conc. 14,
(Orillia) .
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to David Anderson in the amount of $130.00.
(m) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 lamb killed
wolves, lamb owned by Gordon Wagar, Lot 8, Conc. 6, (Oro).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to Gordon Wagar in the amount of $150.00.
(n) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 lamb killed
wolves, lamb owned by Gordon Wagar, Lot 8, Conc. 6, (Oro).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to Gordon Wagar in the amount of $125.00.
(0) Ernest Bidwell, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 lamb killed
wolves, lamb owned by Gordon Wagar, Lot 8, Conc. 6, (Oro).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to Gordon Wagar in the amount of $125.00.
(p) Michael vandergeest, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 calf
killed by wolves, calf owned by Don Bell, Lot 13, Conc. 13,
(Medonte) .
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to Don Bell in the amount of $700.00.
e
(q) Michael Vandergeest, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 calf
killed by wolves, calf owned by Peter Lumree, Lot 19, Conc. 7,
(Medonte).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized
make compensation to Peter Lumree in the amount of $700.00.
(r) Mervin Faris, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 calf killed by
wolves, calf owned by Donald Woodrow, Lot 2, Conc. 7,
(Medonte) .
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized to
make compensation to Donald Woodrow in the amount of $200.00.
(s) Jack Anderson, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 heifer killed by
wolves, heifer owned by Doug Briggs, Lot 12, Conc. 10, (Oro).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized to
make compensation to Doug Briggs in the amount of $950.00.
(t) Mervin Faris, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 calf killed by
wolves, calf owned by James Lawlor, Lot 5, Conc. 11,
(Medonte) .
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized to
make compensation to James Lawlor in the amount of $300.00.
3.
(u)
4.
(a)
e
(b)
(c)
( d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
(i)
(j)
(k)
(I)
(m)
(n)
e
(0)
(p)
- 5 -
CONSENT AGENDA CORRESPONDENCE CONTINUED: j
Jack Anderson, Livestock Valuer Report, re: 1 ewe killed b
wolves, ewe owned by Bev Gough, Lot 1, Conc. 9, (Medonte).
Recommendation: Receive and the Treasurer be authorized t
make compensation to Bev Gough in the amount of $200.00.
REPORT OF MUNICIPAL OFPICERS:
Ron Kolbe, Chief Building Official, reports re: Monthl
Building Report for June and July.
Ron Kolbe, Chief Bylaw Enforcement Officer, confidentia
report re: Bay Animal Control and Dog Tag Revenue.
Mark stagg, Planner, report re: Proposed Zoning Bylaw, Hedbur
Homes, Block 47, Part Lot 41, Conc. 1 (former Twp. Flos).
Mark stagg, Planner, report re: The Sabiston, Valdoro an
Buffalo springs Developments Environment Committee.
Mark stagg, Planner, report re: Proposed Subdivision,1
Horseshoe Highlands Phase 2B Salvil Investments Ltd., Part LO~
1, Conc. 4 (Oro). [
Andria Leigh, Secretary-Treasurer, Committee of Adjustment,1
report re: Planning Reports/Committee Decisions June 15, 1995.1
I
i
Mark stagg, Planner, report re: OMB Appeal, Lindsay, Part Lot~
2 and 3, Conc. 12 (former Medonte). I
I
Mark stagg, Planner, report re: Progress Report, preparatio~
of Official Plan. I
Gary Cunnington, C.A.O., confidential memo re: Recreatio~1
Facilities Foreman. "
II
,
Jeff Brydges, Deputy Treasurer, memo re: Interim Policies fo
Planning Applications and Developer Deposits.
Jeff Brydges, Deputy
Expenditure Reductions
Friday, July 21, 1995.
provincia
of Financ
Treasurer, memo re:
Announced by Minister
Darlene Shoebridge, Clerk, memo re: Request for Temporar
Trailer While New Home Being Constructed, Lot 3, Plan M-11~1
(Medonte) . il
il
Ii
Ian Beard, Mayor, report re: Fences at Eight Mile Point.
Ii
Ian Beard, Mayor, report re: Proposed Policy with regard t~1
Developer Trust funds and Letter of Credit. II
11
Fred Haughton, Public Works Administrator, confidential repor~1
re: Employee Personnel. II
Gary cunnington, C . A. O. ,
Facilities Foreman.
Ii
ii
confidential memo re: Recreatioql
"
5. COMMUNICATIONS:
(a) Trillium Manor/Hillcrest Lodge, correspondence re: Requestin9
permission to Use Name Oro-Medonte For New Wing.
(b) Horseshoe Resort corporation, correspondence re: Extension of
Liquor License For special Event.
- 6 -
5. COMMUNICATIONS CONTINUED:
(c) Dorothy and Mike Pidwerbecki, correspondence re: Request for
Exception to By-law to Allow For 4 Dogs on Property, Lot 10,
Conc. 10 (Oro).
I
(d) Roger and Fredda French, correspondence re: Owners of Lot 10,1
Conc. 10 (Oro) Supporting Request for Exception to By-law to
Allow for 4 Dogs on Property.
e
(e) Simcoe County Residents Against Market Value Reassessment
(SCRAM), correspondence re: opposing Adoption of Current
County Wide Reassessment Proposal. I
,
I
I
I
I
Be it resolved that the Agenda for the Council Meeting dated I
Wednesday, August 16, 1995, be adopted as printed and circulatedl
,
with the addition of the following: 1
i
,
Gary Cunnington, C. A. 0., conf idential memo re: Recreationll
Facilities Manager. II
Carried. II
il
!I
II
II
Regular Meeting of councill
adopted as pr inted andl
I
I
!I
. II
carr1ed.11
II
II
II
If
il
Ii
ii
II
II
Be it resolved that the Minutes of the special Meeting of councilll
held on Friday, July 7, 1995 be adopted as printed and circulated. ii
. II
carr1ed.11
fi
9. (p)
MOTION NO. 1
Moved by craig, seconded by Sommers
MOTION NO. 2
Moved by Craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the Minutes of the
held on Wednesday, July 5, 1995 be
circulated.
MOTION NO. 3
Moved by Sommers, seconded by Craig
MOTION NO. 4
Moved by Sommers, seconded by Craig
e
Be it resolved that
held on Wednesday,
circulated.
:i
the Minutes of the special Meeting of Councilll
July 19, 1995 be adopted as printed andll
Ii
Ii
!:
Carried.
MOTION NO. 5
Moved by Martin, seconded by Dickie
Be it resolved that the recommendations listed on the Consent
Agenda, Item No.7, be received and approved.
carried.
- 7 -
MOTION NO. 6
Moved by Bell, seconded by Dickie
Be it resolved that the reports from Ron Kolbe, Chief Buildin
Official, re: Monthly Building Report for June and July, b
received.
Carried.
MOTION NO. 7
e
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
Be it resol ved that the report from Ron Kolbe, Chief By-Ia
Enforcement Officer, re: Bay Animal Control and Dog Tag Revenue, b
received. I
f
I
Carr ied .11
II
II
II
Be it resolved that the report from Mark stagg, Planner re:1
Proposed Zoning Bylaw, Hedburn Homes, Block 47, Part Lot 41, concj
1 (former Twp. Flos) be received and adopted, and the followin1
policy be established: II
That when an Official Plan Amendment of a simpler character ha~fl
been adopted by council and is before the Minister of Municipa~
Affairs for approval, the companion Zoning Bylaw Amendment ,11
containing the necessary clause as to the timing of its coming intq
effect, may, upon the request of the applicant be presented by th~
Oro-Medonte Planner to Council for its consideration and adoption.i
i
Ii
Carried.11
i'
II
MOTION NO. 8
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Martin
MOTION NO. 9
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Martin
i1
II
Be it resolved that the report from Mark Stagg, Planner re: Th~!
sabiston, Valdoro and Buffalo Springs Developments Environmen~1
Commi ttee, be received. II
if
'f
if
. iI
Carr1ed.11
11
MOTION NO. 10
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Martin
e
i!
Be it resol ved that the report from Mark Stagg, Planner re :11
Proposed Subdivision, Horseshoe Highlands Phase 2B Sal vi~1
Investments Ltd., Part Lot 1, Conc. 4 (Oro), be received adopted .11
I
carried.1
MOTION NO. 11
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
Be it resolved that the report from Andria Leigh, Secretary..,
Treasurer, Committee of Adjustment, re: Planning Reports/Committe~
Decisions June 15, 1995, be received.
Carried.
- 8 -
MOTION NO. 12
Moved by Sommers, seconded by Craig
Be it resolved that the report from Mark Stagg, Planner re:
Appeal, Lindsay, Part Lots 2 and 3, Conc. 12 (former Medonte),
received and adopted.
Recorded vote requested by: councillor Bell
e
Councillor Bell
Councillor craig
Councillor Dickie
Deputy Mayor Martin
Councillor Sommers
Mayor Beard
Nay
Yea
Nay
Nay
Nay
Nay
Defeated
MOTION NO. 13
Moved by Sommers, seconded by craig
Be it resolved that the report from Mark Stagg, Planner re:
Progress Report, Preparation of Official Plan, be received.
Carried.
MOTION NO. 14
Moved by craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the memo from Jeff Brydges, Deputy Treasurer,
re: Interim Policies for Planning Applications and
Deposi ts, be recei ved and referred to the September
Committee of the Whole.
Carried.
MOTION NO. 15
Moved by Martin, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the fence located on Lot 92, Plan 780, 8
Point (Gilchrist & Softly) be lowered at the south end
approximately 1 foot to assist in alleviating a possible
visibility problem encroaching from the neighbouring property.
and further this alteration be made within 2 weeks from this date.
Recorded vote requested by: Councillor Sommers
e
Councillor Sommers
Deputy Mayor Martin
Councillor Dickie
Councillor craig
Councillor Bell
Mayor Beard
Yea
Yea
Yea
Yea
Yea
Yea
carried.
MOTION NO. 16
Moved by Martin, seconded by Bell
Be it resolved that the memo from Jeff Brydges, Deputy Treasurer,
re: Provincial Expendi ture Reductions Announced by Minister of
Finance Friday, July 21, 1995, and effect on 9th Line (Medonte)
Reconstruction be received and adopted.
Defeated.
- 9 -
MOTION NO. 17
Moved by Craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the tenders for the 4th Line Watermain to
service new firestation headquarters (Horseshoe Valley) be received
and the low tender of Kulson Kontracting & Management at a cost of
$89,655.30 (bore cut) be accepted subject to confirmation by the
appropriate staff and consulting engineers.
Carried. I
e
MOTION NO. 18
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Martin
Be it resolved that the memo from Darlene Shoebridge, Clerk, re:
Request for Temporary Trailer While New Home Being Constructed, Lot
3, Plan M-112 (Medonte) be received and adopted.
MOTION NO. 19
Carried. I
I
I
I
I
II
atl
Moved by Martin, seconded by Bell
Be it resolved that the report from Ian Beard, Mayor, re: Fences
Eight Mile Point, be received.
. I
Carr1ed.1
I
I
MOTION NO. 20
f
Moved by Martin, seconded by Bell I
II
. Ii
Be 1 t resolved that the report from Ian Beard, Mayor, re: Proposed II
Policy with regard to Developer Trust Funds and Letter of Credit, II
and Agendas for Department Heads be received and adopted. II
II
carried.!1
"
II
II
II
II
II
MOTION NO. 21 II
!I
Moved by Sommers, seconded by Craig II
I!
. . Ii
Be it resolved that the correspondence from Tr11l1umll
. .. il
Manor/Hillcrest Lodge, re: RequestJ.ng Perm1SSJ.on to Use Name of!1
Oro-Medonte For New Wing, be received and Council approve of naming!1
a nursing unit the Oro-Medonte wing.
e
Carried.
MOTION NO. 22
Moved by Craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the 9th Line (Medonte) Reconstruction Project!!
be limited to $96,250.00 for 1995 due to recent Provincial!
Expenditure Reductions affecting the 1995 Roads Supplementary!1
allocation.
Carried.
- 10 -
MOTION NO. 23
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
Be it resolved that the correspondence from Horseshoe Resorl
Corporation, re: Extension of Liquor Licence for Special Events, b
received and approved. I
Carried.
MOTION NO. 24
e
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
Be it resol ved that the correspondence from Dorothy and Mik
Pidwerbecki re: Request for Exception to By-law to Allow For 4 Dog
on Property, Lot 10, Conc. 10 (Oro), be received and request b
denied.
MOTION NO. 25
Carried.
!
i
!
II
II
Moved by Bell, seconded by Dickie
Be it resol ved that the correspondence from Roger and Fredd~
French, re: Owners of Lot 10, Conc. 10 (Oro) supporting Request fo~
Exception to By-law to Allow For 4 Dogs on Property, be received.1
f
f
Carried.!
MOTION NO. 26
Moved by Bell, seconded by Dickie II
Ii
II
Be it resolved that the correspondence from Simcoe County Residentsl
Against Market Value Reassessment (SCRAM), re: Opposing Adoption 0~1
Current County Wide Reassessment Proposal, be received.
MOTION NO. 27
carried.11
if
11
Ii
'f
"
"
Ii
"
f'
Moved by Bell, seconded by Dickie
II
Be it resol ved that the Minutes of the Oro-Medonte planningjl
Advisory Committee meeting held August 8, 1995, be received. ..
ii
Carried.!'
e
MOTION NO. 28
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
Be it resolved that Application P-41/95, Barrie Rugby Club, Lot 10,!1
Conc. 1 (Oro) proposal for zoning By-law Amendment for temporar~1
use to allow for a rugby playing and practice field, proceed to ~i
Public Meeting.
Carried.
- 11 -
MOTION NO. 29
Moved by Bell, seconded by Dickie
Be it resolved that we do now go In Camera @ 10:42 p.m.
personnel matters relative to agenda items 13. (a)., 9
and 9 (p).
to discus I
(i), 9 (o~
,
Carried.
MOTION NO. 30
Moved by Dickie, seconded by Bell
e
Be it resolved that we do now Rise and Report from In
11:10 p.m.
f
,
I
Camera 1
. it
carr1ed.1
,
I
f
MOTION NO. 31
Moved by Craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that we suspend rule 21 (d) of Procedural By-law 95
44 in order to allow the meeting to proceed past the norma
adjournment hour of 11:00 p.m.
MOTION NO. 32
carried"1
I
I
I
I
I
Moved by craig, seconded by Martin
MOTION NO. 33
Be it resolved that the confidential memo from Gary cunnington,1
C.A.O., re: Recreation Facilities Foreman, be received and adopted.11
(1) . ii
Ii
II
Carried.11
II
il
\1
I'
II
"
,!
II
II
I'
il
Fred Haughton ,II'
be recei ved an~
II
if
II
Carried.11
Moved by craig, seconded by Sommers
Be it resolved that the confidential report from
Public Works Administrator, re: Employee Personnel,
adopted.
MOTION NO. 34
Be it resolved that the confidential memo from Gary
C.A.O. re: Recreation Facilities Manager be received
(2) .
I!
Ii
. I:
cunn1ngton ,Ii
and adopted;1
e
Moved by Craig, seconded by Martin
Recorded vote requested by: Councillor Sommers
Councillor Bell Yea
Councillor craig Yea
Councillor Dickie Yea
Deputy Mayor Martin Yea
Councillor Sommers Nay
Mayor Beard Yea
Carried.
- 12 -
MOTION NO. 35
Moved by Sommers, seconded by craig
Be it resolved that a By-law to Confirm the Proceedings of Council,
be introduced and read a first and second time and numbered By-law
No. 95-73.
Carried.
That By-law 95-73 be read a third time and finally passed, be
engrossed by the Clerk, signed and sealed by the Mayor.
e
carried.
MOTION NO. 36
Moved by Sommers, seconded by craig
Be it resolved that we do now adjourn @ 11:15 p.m.
Carried.
,;1 r' /!
It ~~4f('~-""" I J' %?~4'i,J. .'
MAYOR IAN BEAItD
4</J~') ~~.h~C7C;t:""
~LERK, DARLENE SHOEBRIDGE v
e