06 17 2019 Heritage Committee Agenda4� �k�
Wi
Township of
Froud Heritage, Exciting Future
Page
1. Agenda Approval:
a) Motion to Approve the Agenda.
The Township of Oro-Medonte
Heritage Committee Agenda
Robinson Room
Monday, June 17, 2019
6:00 p.m.
2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest:
3. Approval of Minutes of Previous Meeting:
2 - 7 a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
4. Communications:
8 a) Correspondence received from Bert Duclos re: Heritage Services.
9 b) Correspondence dated May 19, 2019 from Ally Marino re: Shanty Bay Public
School.
10-38 c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M.
Hodges, and John B. Hodges re: Request for Designation of Home and
Property as a Heritage / Historical Site.
5. Reports of Members of Council/Municipal Officers:
39-49 a) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Draft List of Cairns, Plaques, Monuments,
Cemeteries and Churches in the Township of Oro-Medonte.
50-65 b) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Index of Register of Heritage Listed and
Designated Properties.
66-69 c) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heritage
Resource Evaluation Form.
70 d) Mayor H.S. Hughes; Councillor Keane re: 200th Anniversary Celebration.
6. Next Meeting Date:
Monday, September 16, 2019 (TBC).
7. Adjournment:
a) Motion to Adjourn.
Page 1 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
.'--
�,.
Tnwruhip of
Proud Heritage, Exciting Future
Monday, May 13, 2019
Present:
The Township of Oro-Medonte
Heritage Committee Meeting Minutes
Council Chambers
Mayor H.S. Hughes (left
Councillor Cathy Keane,
Councillor Ian Veitch, Vic
Ruth Fountain
Dorothy Moore
Kayla Thibeault
Bob Tudhope
Regrets: Chris Eaves
Time: 6:00 p.m.
Staff Present: Andria Leigh, Director, Development Services; Catherine McLean,
1.
a)
Planner; Janette Teeter, Supervisor, Clerk's Services/Deputy Clerk
Agenda Approval:
Motion to Approve the Agenda.'
Motion No. HC190513-1
Moved by Moore, Seconded by Fountain
It is recommended that the agenda for the Heritage Committee meeting held on
Monday, May 13, 2019 be received and approved.
NoCarried.
2. Disclosure of Pecuniary Interest:
None declared.
Page 1 of 6
Page 2 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
Heritage Committee Minutes — Monday, May 13, 2019.
3. Approval of Minutes of Previous Meeting:
a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, April 15, 2019.
Motion No. HC190513-2
Moved by Thibeault, Seconded by Tudhope
It is recommended that the draft minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on
Monday, April 15, 2019 be received and approved as printed and circulated.
Carried.
4. Communications: AA66
a)
Correspondence dated May 6, 2019 from Bertrand (Bert) Duclos, Heritage Outreach
Consultant, Libraries, Arts and Heritage Services Unit, Ministry of Tourism, Culture and
Sport re: Proposed Amendments to the Ontario Heritage Act.
A161 '14h" N
Motion No. HC190513-3
Moved by Thibeault, Seconded I
It is recommended
1. That the correspondence dated May 6, 2019 from Bertrand (Bert) Duclos, Heritage
Outreach Consultant, Libraries, Arts and Heritage Services Unit, Ministry of Tourism,
Culture and Sport re: Proposed Amendments to the Ontario Heritage Act be
received.
2. That staff bring forward the proposed regulations and guidance documents for
further review by the Committee when available for Provincial Consultation.
IV '% X� Carried.
b) Correspondence from Community Heritage Ontario (CHO) re: Quarterly Publication,
Spring 2019.
Motion No. C190513-74
Moved by Tudhope, Seconded by Thibeault
It is recommended that the correspondence from Community Heritage Ontario (CHO)
re: Quarterly Publication, Spring 2019 be received.
Carried.
Page 2of6
Page 3 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
Heritage Committee Minutes — Monday, May 13, 2019.
5. Reports of Members of Council/Municipal Officers:
a) Ruth Fountain re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cemetery Signage.
Motion No. HC190513-5
Moved by Fountain, Seconded by Thibeault
It is recommended
1. That the verbal information presented by Ruth Fountain re: Township of Oro-
Medonte Cemetery Signage be received.
2. That it is recommended to Council that appropriate signage, if required, be posted at
the Township cemeteries.
3. That the matter be referred to 2020 budget deliberations
Carried.
b) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Draft Heritage Committee Strategic Work Plan (2018-
2022 Term of Council) [from April 15, 2019 meeting],
Motion No. HC190513-6
Moved by Thibeault, Seconded I
It is recommended l w _
1. That the correspondence dated May 13, 2019 and presented by Catherine McLean,
Planner re: Draft Heritage Committee Strategic Work Plan (2018-2022 Term of
Council) be received and approved.
2. That it is recommended to Council that the Heritage Committee Strategic Work Plan
(2018-2022 Term of Council), per the Heritage Committee By -Law No. 2019-021, be
endorsed.
1%L 1% 1% Carried.
Page 3of6
Page 4 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
Heritage Committee Minutes — Monday, May 13, 2019.
c) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Draft List of Cairns, Plaques, Monuments, Cemeteries
and Churches in the Township of Oro-Medonte.
Motion No. HC190513-7
Moved by Moore, Seconded by Tudhope
It is recommended
1. That the correspondence dated May 13, 2019 and presented by Catherine McLean,
Planner re: Draft List of Cairns, Plaques, Monuments, Cemeteries and Churches in
the Township of Oro-Medonte be received.
2. That updates, as discussed, be completed and the working document be brought
back to the next Heritage Committee meeting.
Carried.
d) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Index of Register of Heritage Designated and Listed
Properties.
Motion No. HC190513-8
Moved by Thibeault, Seconded by Tudhope
It is recommended
1. That the correspondence dated May 13, 2019 and presented by Catherine McLean,
Planner re: Index of Register of Heritage Designated and Listed Properties be
received.
2. That updates, as discussed, be completed and the working document be brought
back to the next Heritage Committee meeting.
Carried.
e) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of Oro-Medonte Books Donation to Schools
within the Township of Oro-Medonte.
Motion No. HC190513-9
Moved by Moore, Seconded by Tudhope
It is recommended
1. That the verbal information presented by Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of
Oro-Medonte Books Donation to Schools within the Township of Oro-Medonte be
received.
2. That it is recommended to Council that the schools, located within the Township of
Oro-Medonte, receive a complimentary copy of the Township books, as applicable.
3. That staff coordinate the matter accordingly.
Carried.
Page 4of6
Page 5 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
Heritage Committee Minutes — Monday, May 13, 2019.
f) Mayor H.S. Hughes re: Legend of the Drinking Gourd book by W. Allen Fisher.
Motion No. HC190513-10
Moved by Moore, Seconded by Fountain
It is recommended
1. That the verbal information presented by Mayor H.S. Hughes re: Legend of the
Drinking Gourd book by W. Allen Fisher be received.
2. That it is recommended to Council upon receipt of written confirmation from Mark
Fisher:
• the said book be posted on the Township's website;
• the said book be reproduced by Township Staff, upon request, in accordance
with the Township Fees & Charges By -Law;
• staff investigate the cost of reprinting the book and bring back the matter to a
future Heritage Committee meeting.
Carried.
g) Councillor Keane re: 200th Anniversary Celebration
Motion No. HC190513-11
Moved by Tudhope, Seconded by Thibeault
It is recommended that the verbal information presented by Mayor H.S. Hughes and
Councillor Keane re: 200th Anniversary Celebrations be received.
Carried.
Mayor H.S. Hughes left the meeting;
h) Catherine McLean re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation
Form.
Motion No. HC190513-12
Moved by Moore, Seconded by Tudhope
It is recommended
1. That the Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation Form
presented by Catherine McLean be received.
2. That an updated form and allocation of resource plan be brought back to the next
Heritage Committee meeting.
Carried.
Page 5of6
Page 6 of 70
3.a) Minutes of Heritage Committee meeting held on Monday, May 13, 2019.
Heritage Committee Minutes — Monday, May 13, 2019.
6. Next Meeting Date:
Monday, June 17, 2019 (TBC).
7. Adjournment:
a) Motion to Adjourn.
Motion No. HC190513-13
Moved by Thibeault, Seconded by Moore
It is recommended that we do now adjour
Councillor Keane, Chair Janette Teeter, Deputy Clerk
10
Carried.
Page 6of6
Page 7 of 70
a
'Ifen"lage
Bertrand (Bert) Duclos
416-839-1654 — bertduclos@bell. net
bertduclosheritage.ca
What I Do
Over 30 years in the private sector and over 15 years in
the cultural heritage community as a consultant,
volunteer and public servant provides me with a wealth
of skill, knowledge and practical experience to offer a
wide range of services to municipalities, heritage
conservation groups and the public. Available province
wide, the rates for these services can be tailored to
multi or single groups.
* Municipal Heritage Committee orientation
* Ontario Heritage Act training
* property research
* property evaluation
* Ontario Heritage Act designation reports
* Ontario Heritage Act designation by-laws
* stage 1 archaeological reports
* public speaking & engagement
estimoniais
a$ert's expertise, knowledge, guidance and prompt efficient
!�Zsponses to my many questions have truly helped my
-qunicipality to improve our heritage portfolio."
O - Teri Souter
Manager of Arts, Culture & Heritage, Town of Huntsville
"Bert did a terrific job with all the material and was a very
engaging speaker. His information was well presented and
included a note of humour now and then. He was able to
answer questions as we went along and then return to the
presentation seamlessly."
- Sheryl Smith
Chairperson, Selwyn Municipal Heritage Committee
My Success Stories
* created and conducted over 120 cultural heritage
conservation workshops for over 300 municipalities and
400 groups
* wrote A Guide to Effective Municipal Heritage
Committees, to provide contextual information,
examples of best practices, and aids in identifying and
overcoming challenges
* contributed to the Toronto Region Conservation
Authority's award winning Crossing The Humber:
The Humber River Heritage Bridge Inventory
* contributed to the development of provincial cultural
heritage conservation policies and legislation
* second longest serving municipal heritage committee
advisor with the Ministry of Culture
More About My Story
My over 30 years in the private sector employed by
multinational corporations in marketing and sales
management gives me valuable insight in how to inspire
others and help them convey the benefits of engaged
cultural heritage conservation. In the performance of my
service offer I conform to accepted technical and ethical
standards and work in accordance with the regulations and
guidelines of my heritage field and the jurisdictions of
practice.
Volunteer activities of note includes:
* Doors Open Ontario Committee
* Communities in Bloom Committee
* Regional Municipal Cultural Planning Steering Committee
* Historical Society Board of Directors
* Community Museum Board of Management
* Community newsletter editor
* Community website master
Recognition includes:
* Municipal Volunteer Special Recognition Award for civic
heritage conservation and promotion activities
* Ontario Heritage Trust Certificate for cultural
activities under its Heritage Community Recognition
Program
Who I Am
As a Heritage Outreach Consultant with the Ontario
Ministry of Culture for over 12 years, I provided province
wide consultation, advice, liaison, community capacity
building, outreach, education and training services to a
broad and diverse range of heritage conservation and
culture stakeholders/organizations, including
municipalities, Municipal Heritage Committees, heritage
and other cultural organizations.
During this time, I was also the primary municipal and
public point of liaison for strategic advisory services ons''
cultural heritage conservation best practices and use ofo
legislative tools including the Ontario Heritage Act the
CD
Planning Act, the Building Code Act and the Funeral,
(n
Burials and Cremations Services Act.
p
Z3
While at the Ministry, I reviewed, advised and
Q
(D
commented on hundreds of both draft and final
Z3
municipal cultural heritage designation by-laws.
0
(D
Before the Ministry, I worked as a private heritage
(D
consultant. During this time I conducted
(D
archaeological historic research for a conservation
<
(D
authority, acted as a project manager for a heritage
Q
conservation district study and plan, and worked with
0-1
municipalities and heritage committees to create
3
cultural heritage evaluation systems, research and
00
evaluate properties, write designation reports and spea!�
to councils and the public
C=
err'ntario
'
O
(D
al Heritage Committees
ng and sustaining an effective
heritage committee
(D
�-
r �
G
(D
4.b) Correspondence dated May 19, 2019 from Ally Marino re: Shanty Bay P...
From: Ally Marino
Sent: May 19, 2019 7:57 PM
To: cmclean (a)-oro-medonte.ca
Subject: Oro Medonte Heritage Committee
Hello! My name is Ally Marino and I was hoping to touch base with you about the Oro Medonte
Heritage Committee.
I am a parent of three girls who attend Shanty Bay Public School and it has come to the parents'
attention that the board has diverted funds and allowed the school to fall into disrepair. There is
evidence of this in the 2019 capital plan that the board released in March. When parents contacted to
the board they insist that they have done repairs but when asked for evidence of this they have yet to
provide it. It appears that the board is doing this intentionally so they can relocate the students
without officially closing the school, as there is a moratorium on school closures. They say it is a
"temporary" relocation but it will not be. They have deemed the school "prohibitive to repair" which
means they are not going to fix anything that breaks. They are going to relocate the students until the
moratorium is lifted and then close the school officially. There is a large community wide concern for
the building and school, as it has been a pivotal cornerstone of this community for 100 years! Once
the school is closed they will be quick to sell it and then who knows what will happen to this important
structure. The community has been meeting weekly to organize and fight the closure and subsequent
tear down of the building. Several generations of long-standing community members have come to
the meetings to state their concern. Is there a way to initiate identifying this property for consideration
as a heritage building? We just want to protect this building and the school that means so much to the
community. The school board is looking at dollars and sense and completely ignoring the value that
this building has on our community.
Thank you for taking the time to listen to these concerns and I look forward to hearing from you.
Ally Marino
This email was scanned by Bitdefender
Page 9 of 70
4.c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H...
June 11, 2019
Glenn B. Hodges
Laura M. Hodges
John B. Hodges
5379 Wyndam Lane
Brighton, MI 48116
Request for Designation of Home and Property as a Heritage / Historical Site
Dear Members of the Oro-Medonte Township Heritage Committee:
We are contacting you to request that the home and property located at 567 Line 11 S., Section
R01-39 (Concession 12, Lot 24), be designated as a protected heritage / historical site. This
home was previously listed in the historical register on March 28, 2018 under Heritage Motion
#HC180319-5 and Council Motion #C180328-9.
Prior to explaining the reason for this request, we would like to clarify our connection to this
home and property. We are the direct descendants of Richard Hodges who built this home no
later than 1844. The direct line of descent is: Richard Hodges / William Hodges / John A. Hodges
/ John B. Hodges / John B. Hodges / Glenn B. and Laura M. Hodges / John B. Hodges. Richard
Hodges is the great, great, great grandfather of Glenn B. and Laura M. Hodges, who are siblings,
and the great, great, great, great grandfather of John B. Hodges, who is the son of Glenn B.
Hodges. This home was in our family for around 100 years when it was sold to the Girl Guides of
Canada in 1938.
There are numerous reasons why this home should be granted a designation as a heritage /
historical site. The most fundamental of these reasons pertains to the fact that the town of
what is now known as "Hawkestone", was originally founded by Richard Hodges, as the town of
"Hodges' Landing" and that the home and property in question were a major focus of activity
during the years after the founding of the town and its early development. There is a wealth of
evidence, provided below, to support this fundamental assertion.
The property on which St. Helen's is built is Concession 12, Lot 24 in what is now Hawkestone.
This property was purchased by Richard Hodges in 1830 (History of Simcoe County, p. 142). He
had arrived from Bridgewater, England in 1830 with his wife Ann (Kith 'N Kin, p. 155; The Story
of Oro, p. 256). There is a great deal of evidence indicating Richard Hodges was very actively
developing this property and his business in the early 1830s. An example of this can be found in
the History of Simcoe Country by Andrew F. Hunter, 1909. "Hodges' Landing received its name
Page 10 of 70
4.c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H...
from Richard Hodges, a native of England, who settled there in 1830, on lot 24 beside Lake
Simcoe, and his son, William, born here in 1834, may also be classed among the pioneers. Capt.
Davis settled on the east side of the Hawkestone Creek about the same time as Richard Hodges
on the west side." "Duncan Gilchrist was one of the prominent settlers in the northern tract
now under review. In 1813, Mr. Gilchrist had belonged to the volunteer coast guard in the west
of Scotland, under the Duke of Argyle. He came from Bowmore, Islay, in 1834, with his family,
landed at Hodges' Landing, and they made their way along the rough settlers' road and through
the bush to lot 6 in the 8th concession, some two miles or more northwest of Galbraith's
Corner." (History of Simcoe Country, p. 154). Another set of references from the same book
includes the following: "The traveller who embarked at Holland Landing could make for "The
Narrows," or "Shingle Bay," or Hodge's (sic) Landing (Hawkestone), or Kempenfeldt, or "The
Head of the Bay," from all of which places were trails leading across to Georgian Bay; and
according to the traveller's destination, so was his course through Lake Simcoe. At an early
date, Hodges' Landing, now known as Hawkestone, took an important position amongst these
landing places; and many people landed there on their way into the northern part of Oro and
into Medonte. So considerable was the influx at that point, about 1832, that Wellesley Richie,
the Government Agent, remained with gangs of men on the Coldwater Road, at Bass Lake, to
place new settlers on their lands, both those who came via Hodges' Landing and those who
landed at "The Narrows." "A colonization road into upper Oro was cut through from Hodges'
Landing at an early date, and joined with the earlier route from Kempenfeldt to
Penetanguishene, at Dalston of the present. The Hodges' Landing road soon became a feeder of
the Penetanguishene Road, and owing to hills and the big swamp on the lower portion of the
latter, it probably shared for a time as much as, if not more traffic than, the Kempenfeldt part
of the same route. But in 1847, through the instrumentality of the Hon. W. B. Robinson,
Commissioner of Public Works, and member of the Legislative Assembly for Simcoe, the
Kempenfeldt-Penetanguishene Road was thoroughly cleared out to the width of sixty-six feet,
and made passable for its entire length of over thirty miles. This step removed any further
necessity for using the Hodges' Landing road. But, as late as 1851, we find the road distinctly
marked on the county map in Smith's "Canada: Past, Present, and Future," which, however,
might have been copied from some old map, as one map -maker copies from another." (History
of Simcoe County, P. 142 —143). Another reference from the same book worth noting is that
under the heading "Settlers Before 1837" it references Richard Hodges owning Concession 12,
Lot 24 (History of Simcoe County, p. 298).
Initial wooden structures were erected shortly after the purchase of the land. The structures
were used for housing for the family, as well as housing for settlers arriving into the
Hawkestone area, while their cabins were being built. Richard Hodges also had a store and
provided provisions for the incoming settlers (Kith 'N Kin, p. 155) and in various sources was
identified as a farmer, a merchant and an inn keeper, all of which appear to have been correct.
The land agent, Wellesley Richey, had his headquarters at Hodges' Landing from 1831-1832
(Kith 'N Kin, p. 155; The Story of Oro, p. 257). By 1844, Richard Hodges had built the home in
question, known as St. Helens. This is best evidenced by two images made by Titus Hibbert
Ware, which are located at the Toronto Public Library. The first was done in pen, brown ink and
Page 11 of 70
4.c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H...
watercolor showing the right rear side of the home and outbuildings with the wharf
(https://www.torontopubliclibrary.ca/detail. isp?Entt=RDMDC-PICTU RES-R-388&R=DC-PICTU RES -R-388).
The second was done in pen and brown ink and shows the left rear side of the home and
outbuildings, the wharf and the British flag
(https://www.torontopubliclibrary.ca/detail. isp?Entt=RDMDC-PICTU RES-R-387&R=DC-PICTU RES -R-387).
Both are dated 19 September 1844. It is noteworthy that if you go to Google and type in
"Hawkestone, Ont.", two images appear, one of which is the first of these two images. Also, at
the Toronto Public Library, if you type in "Hawkestone, Ont." under their search function, three
images appear, two of which are the paintings mentioned above. In other words, St. Helens is a
major face to the world for Hawkestone to this day.
Additional references to Hodges' Landing are indicated on a series of maps at the Simcoe
County Archives dating between 1841 and 1853 (e.g. 1850 map of North Simcoe County, 979-38
#1, among two others) which was sometimes referred to as "Hodges' Wharf" (Map of the
County of Simcoe revised and improved by W. Gibbard, P.LA., 1853)
There are other important connections to the community that Hodges Landing and St. Helen's
have had for nearly 190 years. The wharf at Hodges' Landing and St. Helen's is also connected
to the maritime history of Lake Simcoe. There are multiple references to the Peter Robinson,
built in 1832 and launched in 1834 and one of the earliest steamers on Lake Simcoe as
travelling on a regular basis to Hodges' Landing. This ship was renamed "The Simcoe" in 1839
after an overhaul. (The Story of Oro, p. 113 and from the Maritime Records at the Simcoe
County Archive). There are also other references to steamers landing at Hodges' Landing. For
example: "The calling places for the steamer in this township were Shanty Bay and Hodges, now
the flourishing Village of Hawkestone." (Pioneer Papers, p. 25). Another example includes the
following: "The Emily May's ports of calling included Holland Landing, Belle Ewart, Beaverton,
Orillia, Hodges Landing and Barrie." (The Story of Oro, p. 113.) The fact that there was a
"Hodges' Landing Road", which originated on the property where St. Helen's is located, and
used to facilitate immigrants' relocation into the Medonte and the Georgian Bay area is also of
note. In addition, following the sale of the property and St. Helens to the Girl Guides of Canada
in 1938, this home and property have served as the "Bonita Glen Girl Guide Camp" since 1940.
(Several years ago, Glenn B. Hodges was told by a local historian that this home was the origin
of Girl Guide cookies. The home's roof needed repair and a bake sale was held to raise money
for the new roof. This worked so well that it was carried over into other money raising efforts
and the on-going sale of Girl Guide cookies. Glenn is currently working with the Girl Guides to
see if this is true.)
Another potential historical link relates to the possibility that this property and home was the
most extreme northern end of the "underground railway" for people of African descent
escaping slavery in the southern US. This was told to Glenn B. Hodges by a local historian, not as
a fact, but as more of a speculation, which has been discussed among local historians. This may
be due to the fact there were one or more underground tunnels leading from the shore to the
Page 12 of 70
4.c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H...
home with a hidden staircase and door. Other speculations include that it may have been used
to smuggle fish or alcohol, though none of these speculations has been confirmed.
There is also an official historical marker on a large granite boulder near to the property, which
includes a number of details regarding the wharf, the "large house called St. Helen's (1844)",
the tunnels, the steamers and some other facts. The marker is titled: "Historic Hawkestone
(Hodges' Landing) and was provided by the Township of Oro-Medonte; Ian Beard, Mayor; July
1, 2001 A Millennium Project With the generous participation of the Simcoe County Council,
and Historical Association."
Although there is undoubtedly far more to the story of Hodges' Landing and St. Helen's, we
believe the above information makes a strong case for the designation of St. Helen's and the
accompanying property at Concession 12, Lot 24 as a heritage / historical site. We respectfully
request that the members of the Oro-Medonte Township Heritage Committee give this there
full consideration.
Please feel free to contact Glenn B. Hodges at his e-mail address: aworld2c2002@vahoo.com or
his cell phone at (248) 961-1612 if you have questions regarding the above information or
regarding any other aspect of the request for heritage / historical designation.
Thank you and best regards,
Dr. Glenn Black Hodges, PhD
Laura Marie Hodges
John Black Hodges
Page 13 of 70
4.c) Correspondence dated June 11, 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H...
From: Glenn Hodges <aworld2c2002@yahoo.com>
Sent: Friday, June 14, 2019 12:15 PM
To: McLean, Catherine <cmclean @oro-medonte. ca>; John Hodges
<123rustyshackleford@gmail.com>
Subject: St. Helen's as a Hotel
CAUTION:
This email originated from outside of Oro-Medonte's email system. Do
not open links or attachments you were not specifically expecting, even
from known senders. If you have any doubts, please contact I.T.
Dear Catherine,
I just had a couple more thoughts I wanted to share with you regarding St. Helen's. In
the paintings by Titus Hibbert Ware, it refers to St. Helen's as "Hodges Hotel". This
speaks to the nature of Richard Hodges' on-going efforts dating back to at least 1831 to
provide housing for in -coming settlers, but may represent an evolution in his thinking to
provide a more sophisticated and enjoyable experience along the lines of an actual
hotel where people would visit for reasons of leisure rather than to simply facilitate
relocation. I do not know if this was his intent, but it suggests to me that he was referring
to it as a hotel, otherwise it is somewhat unlikely the artist would have simply named it a
hotel. I also wonder how this artist came to make these paintings. Did Richard Hodges
pay him to do so or was this something he did of his own volition as he was passing
through the area? I found a little more artwork from this artist and it has the common
theme of residences in the area around lake Simcoe and beyond. I tried to see if I could
learn a little more about him as an individual and will be receiving some materials today
from the Toronto Public Library. There is an entire chapter on him in the East Georgian
Bay Historical Journal from 1981. If there is anything else relevant to Hodges' Landing
or St. Helen's, I will let you know.
In any case, it may also be appropriate to think of St. Helen's as the first hotel in
Hawkestone or possibly on Lake Simcoe.
Please let me know if you have any questions or additional information.
Thank you and best regards,
Glenn Hodges
This email was scanned by Bitdefender
Page 14 of 70
V
Correspondence dated Jun�-,Tfl 2019 from Glenn B. Hodges, Laura M. H
E'10 `
910
0
Page 15 of 70
k,
cu
5
70
O IMP dT
CY)
N
iiJ�
O L d I m c+t'
L) �.
c
a
4gA.4,,�-
LAKE
I M, c
f7 0 10 /-e e t a LLs " 4r 1A e Xe cx
I
VL
j r
4.c) Correspondence une 11, 2 frpm Glenn B. qo79es, Caura M. H...
a
Ff#ar
.L 4 04V
tai
oP � '
Page 70
r
1 % Y
i
A � N
OP
4.c) Correspondence dated June11, 19 fromenn B. dge/,L-aura M. H...
{
rA
ID
ld .
I -I
r
�,� *l it v
Page 19 of 70
AO
�.
Aw mm -
e
ti ! •PO
e'
WE
s
s
s�
• �r .. s
ML_
- wr-_
L
-
P;
wr
}
kk
e�
.y
r
ro. ir+
AAWF
"law
low r
Arm
O
k
" r
in
a]
ILI
It it
-1 ip
.3,
wi-
".467
4t
ILI
I
t�
A&I
•-9
-''t
yi�
■��\±� `• _
-44
�} \
�!•��
U�
I
.�
JL.
ir
k
�Tw
:j
-.1
P. -A
JL.
ir
k
�Tw
WO N?Q:
V-ff
.4
F,
ir
ht
K 7
WITZ,15*
At
4-
30
d
Af,
i6
-'A
S W—z
p
74 d,
"
�r, A,
Me.
A,
"Ire
.3
V -
s. dfq
r
iFl
t
06
000p
+� g
Alp
rc i.
arl
rte" °+ _
.may
Vol
1
-4m-
go
S!r
swOro i
r,
s
- '
L
�� y�
.r
'e'
w
� L i
t k
4
s k
LSA
..i
�•a4� ,'r}y .e
J
— t
Ao
' 1 • s
•
ir
v •
R i5' �'+� i air rTa+'�; 'ti•
*. j:. [ •
is
* 56
,
,
Ilp
jd F,��b1i;iilJdkY ka,
i '
++ • 4 U Y• F
it-if:d4.'r51droAAt�fn'i#i?Idiil?id6-aGckl,�r�
{
,f 14
�4
10�
P'-fQ
Koft
41
Pp . I f A
�Y
L L
Ali'.
\Wyr
Yl aic�ric Hawkestune
(Hodges' Landing
-'ttsttiattan ltediaflshadlarL� estshli6�ted epeunpfate�ts d t5 i1a On the hasty of t e creek, theg
Ridge.R�as4, and thloughloul the-rownsh+P. lift the 16306 KWhkrd od�epm � fellowtd thaw trail§
far SMICta, mainly ftem the H rill&h i sle 5. #11..10 a iter srri�vjrig by
1r, truekv %ektleuttnt la dearrh of i Ldcpefndeti r aivd Land paroOAMP,
1944)
'the 4aen ai ati ctivltY eZtlete r1 praiva e4 kdcties of twu uad� 9T0=dlsa alied� and his s$ ohm the. talo „ were
iti]ar snd rir<tddg>b ptaL'r close frc m the cellar en the top
r. Some 1940 tht pr P r't3 as 9a id
'a�n iau#e t9 thek, paxanlF%, 4ekt16>inent sNpfe bufletl au the ptoPerty, [o
`bY Slad¢e4* d ri�ugbX#r f0f 52508 to the Cana¢ibn cquncil ('dr Girt ONid—
R t'ariving dgmmuatty e r a tlxvern (i'), tretol (IL), a Lf4*e (�} and the first t a TWGte* ds, ruse
"lccatad d�,1C .1e Lake earl O f the traok, 'Ch* i9rok geutthosker woo Chat] es�ci 1. 3�o dams (F) and
3 eaitts Cpaed toy� 1 SM) arid 6t
band 11r■in, It is thdn�lgt that he fits[ tm`s16 1va3 established by John°wLttlaiM14an f ) dv Lo sutx4equ4atly lauds tl:a 1st(la bfi ek hj1uLo, as tha Tr->= cornet of the Ridge
Asad ani Llrt iFlt, 1u i95{i a Hary w$urf w4■ tas stttected and the
trams vest ehnag■d tfdm #fad G!S` 1 dndSn®td Han j[itaea
D—ktLg Jai the Wife" re a6uhd. Rw'A1kGfL6ns, AM exteasilro
�-1,t9LtLea" rvdtved',rlfh a feei ht thed (TR). atatt:yardL (AT),
T arch ma4LIVS w4tattowor(4T) ro ouqoly the togqeirk manis
fir. aglRine�. t,4ar ty o■ a8 tdd41ot4 were o3,Lppod M6
I
did ■,.pppkia■ShL ¢ad is 7�eL.L.1t114trHns4uedkhtnu�hdh
a4pt4m64t to') . t946 rhe r■.i',%AV 1■+td shratL�S rho •� ,m,�,�, `
To tripvYs4sa4uL-Abyr•auaoilfaraehsred=uif
, tatx44Skanal Heli. ,�
'+ Aiuttha r.6.I.�y a*eerihtanilti IswlteLL@ea the YiliStt■
datA dof,d seals of Lh■ It4rlan, 19 Y1ao al ads up at oumeraui
tevemi, 6ot4t4, 4tord4 {JrAtudll■e Puddl e'■ S1aro (PS 5Awl
,t- 4raar'4 M6d (fa} Mri,LCt, earrlrri Lad■4 to ih4
1ti+'ka.[rsea die■re1 atdr6'I e+ Ltetl011E Les tiD4■!r, ^ dy-h
aeeiar, 7 h.n!<. 1.4 tktdnr l (F} ■L.e 7rndxd a },{etd■Lri 4
SiaL6., keds coM�pLim.adt u{Il4di4■.- eellaa.TA), k,a1r,eLL e141i■T
� {ki$7, Led h740kidLLt%{!}.
i44ta1r6wtha'te t' ra°1 of YLlwlt4■Ldai kLtiLh4cL Lo tr4FRpetlsete■
al5■aa4�a from 140# Lukm4T to 11m,
f} titie "eawa�r,ir at Jeo•lalsdania • .�e,'-,sh � wr
F 3iera, ldayer ,
tkL Y ®1 A r4�+.
I W51k�s
,. Litiita}rt dLt49ilpuYe,n del Llr■Lo4 C'utIM1d111iflA'uMrh+1�'4nrg M!, , 4T1 RLreMibal Art aalLila�
i
M.,
I �,�� i �1 'r r , x I , ,
r, • , Vii+„ ,�, ;, '� f r
#•
4k Ikl
I �,�� i �1 'r r , x I , ,
r, • , Vii+„ ,�, ;, '� f r
#•
0
Historio H.4wkeatone
(H.odgea' ..aiding)
..: sl NaiLcn 1alLana kid Illy IEfA►411Piis1 ovicaoogi4odia 11d ball 1 an r6r bock o! elle Pgeek.• Ike
-,rd;i 'daad� Ind 1'aran�hrlHere'i6w,m.lkrLp. In Ila l l7Qa Alrhard l�nd$e1 aaia4Fi.1a11 s lsedlc{t
Sur .t3civa, ouiofir 8a4v �aAHWlk lacer, alta I.fiar arilvloy by IY7t. rtailPPP [afEasld �Y.Fse arlolJi
iR IkCr IP 6w4l.Pas m waenk 01 eaiepen:daonh had 1041 CwP+r'.hJp-
�aS®®n+' Wtiaet, sLlnh L8e •trassosl decked-, and kl■ Istf * ha'pll retied 5e. E'rle�'s {9ldlty Y'Iga
kl .ataw pq IYk719fp� 't'lara>•swalu ev.deace of rxnllndtrlrovod lanae.. hbm l■k+ as
1ioC;wa'CIl1.e�1ti6d9ja wol+..w.. {*1fi 4.. eel].r e4 eeP rap glace. $ace rkfJ-d.et Who+lm
iaa [99Ia 14 'Lka.l' PaAa ' io`HiIPS25GO 19 Lb.
.OtitKl l CdamaLl l L140, ehe propsrry uaI ■cid
�g l���Pa4'pasd�ia}YCfa
fm i3SW:l ia[he't'aald�hY {:ea11CL�}4r Url r341$sa.
i_nlifil.a{eenroea3lgrliuranl look }.iPl+lefSloe.itaaflnl hatef0ee(Pt,sai
lioeuelcan atlU er .T%o enryI trnauar wu. C4aelas29R. Nd aamP t05 and
3 nll.Yasund 1 id71j aed. Nam u>V Ls Ll deotit ,h., &i irlrwl m Rl w-eal.hLlahed Sy boom
�g4'ILIi�PeL"7.e1 ■ia a6llgwaiLq bldll LbA LW#P Yalek h&n m. hb Lll N•11 comer of I:he FULLko
`A I&A Illi C,L%I 11 L. Lh 1 k�ba MWV strut xal enoateueled and eia�
q+b4 see.haagd&.Nd'{w"Tf A% l•th MMWkkiha4.
Wrlai 11711E Ilalrau rPl2AaUM&rlidnp4P. Ad4RF1aglVI
11 -1 wl,M1 AlMIdh7 Ileal iPiP.l. rilae1-11' ILT). �
" -d amP.r6re wain 1olrte l +C �CPP4Y ikt Pal■IumaoN
aq .sF.pl toll n4b. flier ryas atyrt6aaH+4M'H ,lleppaP ppl41,
■oP+WaRpILu u:P@@ea ie. TaaLrl ClE rrKln Puead LLm♦Yh'a
Ilgiartdi4e IIPp. So 6ros11lr rar:.eFg lie. ial6aft+lea
tPturip was arlairPd'PY CIUI.EL1 Par i .Fart. "ora
IlereuLtnLL trill _
+It'.ar rhe lwllway T'1111arra({ 18=-114qtIi11•lllyl+
w*rap+sheetaleu+.F+1i11. 1,wa.M.1PapPfa —.4
,raarar, ae.s+l+, .t+ra.{{ I1sllAlaFTn.PIP'+Iters ill;}bat
1 A, tree Clsi.a., 17<lL a'MIPh w+aY5Y+. l�bei. Y111F
tl1+4udors p. ElP1 itgQtea qu IPIi1N I x441 t1. w
rat.lshl�7ipad 71a IRF le{11PlFak selP�tFlalfP'a _
�1A.� lPaiaP •llCla IiA1�MimerI NP1Pt ,II
lalal kxir ®I'sI W er ii:j Pas aW11.1111Pu1Ptrwrion �i�'•9� "
1suq,pF IN■
dM! �b arMIP h i%r1L1e''Lla..ap ! �•� "' '�
eflwad XPraalP4.i� t.loFa 1° " La-lba, -IdPe1
I R +� ilglP daaM1IPG YnPII�w.f ll,rlbNPirh ....lanae
v
c�
CD
W
CD
0
0
June 17, 2019
Draft List of Cairns, Plaques, Monuments, Cemeteries and Churches in the Township of Oro-Medonte
Cairns
Cairn
Description
Location
Photo
Stone Cairn on Huron
Line 3 North
Site
(On private property, can be
seen from the road
East Oro drill shed
• "Records the interesting
East Oro (15/16 Sideroad
"--
cairn
tradition of maintaining a
and Line 11 South)
,
militia in each community`,
�.
prepared to defend
_
against invasion or
=�
insurrection" (Township's
website)
• Huronia historic sites
association
Oro African Church
Line 2
cairn
•` E
�•a
Clowes cairn
30/31 Sideroad & Line 2
t
Page 1 of 11
n
v
CD
CD
r
m
v
iv
m
m
v
r—
W
0
h
n
v
�T
V
0
W
0
3
CD
v
0
CD
0
0
0
Cairn
Description
Location
Photo
E. C. Drury
— —=
Bayview Memorial
Park
• Donated 1944 to the
Township of Oro by
George Kirkpatrick in
Honour of Those from the
Township who served in
our armed forces in the
war 1939 to 1945.
On Lake Simcoe between`
Lines 8 & 9
:gid
1
v
zT
CD
CD
0
r
m
v
iv
CD
CD
v
r
0
h
n
v
�•,
v
(D
U)
0
Page 2 of 11
3
CD
v
CD
0
0
Plaques
Plaque
Description
Location
Photo
Oro African Church
• National historic site
• Simcoe County historic
site
• "Acknowledges the
contribution Blacks made
to the development of the
area, and the unique
situation that brought them
here" (Township's
website).
1645 Line 3 North (Line 3 N
and Old Barrie Road)
a
=_
_
- - -_
Oro War Memorial
833 Line 7 North
y
St. Thomas Church
plaque
28 Church Street
e. 4f
Page 3 of 11
n
cD
cD
r
cD
iv
cD
m
O
r
('
I-
O
iv
(D
CD
O
3
CD
Plaque
Description
Location
Photo
Hawkestone Village
"near firehall"
plaque
Sir Sam Steele plaque
Pioneer in the RCMP
Line 12, just south of Mount
` ?
• County historic site
St. Louis Road East
Old Coldwater Road
1.7 kms north of Price's
plaque
Corners
Langman Homestead
Bass Lake Sideroad and
plaque
Line 13 North
Marian Keith plaque
p q
Teacher and novelist
Old Barrie Road and Line
M 6-
;���
� �7
W
whose characters and
12 South (In front of the old
agaw,
fictional situations
school in Rugby)
r,
reflected what she saw inMEN
f t
her community"
Z
(Township's website).
• Simcoe County historic
site
Reforestation plaque
Old Barrie Road between
Line 7 N and Line 8 N `on
curve of old road'
Black settlement
Ridge Road near Line 1 S
plaque
`0.5 km east of large bridge'
Kempenfeldt Village
• "Outlines a planned
Penetanguishene Road
plaque
settlement for the base of
the Penetanguishene
"Literally on the Old
Road, to match a similarly
Penetanguishene Road,
planned settlement at
between two houses,
Page 4 of 11
v,
n
cD
cD
r
cD
iv
cD
cD
O
r
('
0
n
cn
iv
(D
cn
0
3
CD
Plaque
Description
Location
Photo
Penetanguishene; the
immediately east of the
southern settlement did
town line of Barrie, on the
not materialize"
Shanty Bay road watch for
(Township's website).
green "street signs" labeled
• County historic site
"Penetanguishene Road"
near the bottom of the hill."
(Township's website)
E.C. Drury plaque
. Former Premier of
Penetanguishene Road, just
Ontario, historian, farmer.
north of Highway 11
.'
• Provincial historic site
r
E.C. Drury plaque
"Recognizing his work in
agriculture and
reforestation, and leader of
the..." (the sentence is
incomplete on the website)
United Farmers Union
Simcoe County Agriculture
Old Barrie Road near Line 7
and Reforestation
N
Committee site
Wilberforce plaque
• Records the Black
On Ridge Road, half way
Settlement resulting from
between Barrie and Shanty
the first decree by a
Bay
government to enable
Blacks to acquire land on
equal terms as whites.
• Provincial historic site
Page 5 of 11
n
M
M
r
M
iv
M
M
O
r
('
I-
0
n
(D
CD
0
3
CD
Plaque
Description
Location
Photo
Ed Sutherland
Hodges' Landing
• Acknowledges the
Hawkestone
-
interesting history of a
`
community established to
--
receive settlers.
-
• Township historic site
Juno Beach
Private George Robert
. Private McNutt left the
McNutt Road
McNutt Plaque
home farm in May 1942
for active service in the
Lanark and Renfrew
Scottish Regiment of The
Canadian Infantry Corps
= - --
leaving his widowed
-=
mother & brother home on
--
the farm. On October 4th
1944 while serving in the
Perth Regiment, he was
killed in action in Italy at
the young age of 26 years.
Page 6 of 11
l J
CD
CD
r
m
v
iv
CD
CD
v
r
C'
0
n
v
CD
iv
CD
CD
0
Z3
3
CD
v
m
Cn
0
0
Monuments
Monument
Description
Location
Photo
Sir Sam Steele
. Pioneer in the RCMP
Mount St. Louis Road
monument
. County historic site
East and Line 11 North
Old Coldwater Road
. "Acknowledges the importance
"East side of Highway 12,
Old Town Hall
. Township monument records the
833 Line 7 North
Cenotaph
names of those who fought in
the two world wars.'''
• Township historic site
Four -Township War
Background on Tay Township's
Waverly
Memorial (Tiny, Tay,
FIGS and Oro-
website:
https://taVtownshipheritage.wordpress.com/waverly/
(Penetanguishene Road
and Vasey Road)
Medonte)
Historic Sites
Historic Site
Description
Location
Photo
Site of Cahiague
Highway 12
Native Village
Old Coldwater Road
. "Acknowledges the importance
"East side of Highway 12,
of the road (originally a Native
just south of Warminster"
Indian Trail) in the pioneer
settlement of Medonte"
(Township's website).
. A Simcoe County site.
Page 7 of 11
l J
�F
cD
r
cD
iv
cD
cD
O
F_
(n
0
n
cn
(D
cn
0
3
CD
Cemeteries
Cemeteries
Description
Location
Photo
Leigh's Corner
• Township took over the
15/16 Sideroad and Line 12:
Cemetery
cemetery in 2014
(Part East Half Lot 16,
• Dedicated to the memory
Concession 12, Oro, Being
of John Leigh Family
Part 2, Plan 51 R-38899)
s
Abandoned Cemetery
Lot 10, Concession 6 (Oro)
F
i 1
Moon Private
Lot 15, Concession 9
Cemetery
(Medonte)
African Methodist
Lot 11, Concession 4 (Oro)
Episcopal Church
Cemetery
Rugby Cemetery
Lot 11, Concession 12 Oro
v,
n
i•I,
(D
O
Page 8 of 11
3
CD
v
CD
0
0
Churches
Church
Description
Location
Photo
St. Thomas Church
• "A unique example of a
28 Church Street (Shanty
- -
building constructed with
Bay)
walls made of rammed
earth, hay, and when
available, eggs"
(Township's website)
• Provincial historic site
-
• Listed in the Township's
Register
Oro African Church
• National historic site
1645 Line 3 North (Line 3 N
• Simcoe County historic
and Old Barrie Road)
site
• "Acknowledges the
contribution Blacks made
to the development of the
area, and the unique
+-
situation that brought them
..
here" (Township's
" =
website
Betheda
• 1859-1899
Barrie Road west of Line 4
r
Congregational Church
green number next door
r4l�r
1568
Coulson Church
• Listed in the Township's
301 Horseshoe Valley Rd.
Register
W.
Knox Presbyterian
• Listed in the Township's
1604 Old Barrie Rd. E.
Church
Register
Willis Presbyterian
• Listed in the Township's
3353 Line 10 N.
Church
Register
Page 9 of 11
n
v
CD
CD
0
r
m
v
iv
CD
CD
v
_r
CD
0
n
v
cn
iv
CD
cn
0
3
CD
Church
Description
Location
Photo
Esson Presbyterian
. Listed in the Township's
1430 Old Barrie Rd. E.
Church
Register
Central Presbyterian
. Listed in the Township's
80 15/16 Sideroad E. Oro -
Church
Register
Medonte
Oro Station
. Listed in the Township's
697 Line 7 S./703 Line 7 S.
Presbyterian Church
Register
Guthrie Presbyterian
. Listed in the Township's
14 Line 4 N.
Church
Register
Guthrie United Church
. Listed in the Township's
59 Line 4 N.
Register
Hobart Memorial
. Listed in the Township's
4590 Line 6 North, Oro -
Church
Register
Medonte Township
t,.
West Oro Baptist
• Listed in the Township's
1058 Bass Lake Sideroad
Church
Register
West
-
Page 10 of 11
cn
n
v
m
cu
0
r
m
v
iv
m
m
v
r
W'
0
h
n
v
iv
m
0
3
CD
Church
Description
Location
Photo
St. Luke's Anglican
. Listed in the Township's
9160 Hwy. 12 W. Price's
Church, Price's
Register
Corners, ON L3V 6J8
Corners
Mount St. Louis
. Listed in the Township's
4784 Line 4 N.
.;
Church
Register
x:
Sacred Heart Church
. Listed in the Township's
1804 Warminster Sideroad
Register
IM
(D
O
Page 11 of 11
3
cD
Index of Register of Heritage Listed and Designated Properties
June 17, 2019
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-01
Old Town Hall
HC150921-5
C151014-15
14 -Oct -15
833 Line 7 N
R01-02
Rugby Community Hall
HC160118-7
C160127-17
27 -Jan -16
1911 Old Barrie Rd E
R01-03
50 Ridge Road E
HC160418-7
C160427-7
27 -Apr -16
50 Ridge Road E
R01-04
St. Thomas Church
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
4/25/2018
28 Church St. Oro
Bylaw
Station, ON LOL 21-0
2018-043
ZL
R01-05
Coulson Church
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
301 Horseshoe Valley
Rd. W.
R01-06
Knox Presbyterian
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
1604 Old Barrie Rd. E.
Church
R01-07
Willis Presbyterian
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
3353 Line 10 N.
Church
Page 1 of 16
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-08
Esson Presbyterian
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
1430 Old Barrie Rd. E.
Church
R01-09
Central Presbyterian
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
80 15/16 Sideroad E.
Church
Oro-Medonte
R01-10
Oro Station
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
697 Line 7 S./703 Line
Presbyterian Church
7S.
R01-11
Guthrie Presbyterian
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
14 Line 4 N.
Church
R01-12
Guthrie United Church
HC161017-6
C161109-12
9 -Nov -16
59 Line 4 N.
R01-13
Hobart Memorial
HC161121-7
C161214-9
14 -Dec -16
4590 Line 6 North, Oro -
Church
Medonte Township
-A
s
R01-14
Hexagon Concrete Silo
HC161121-7
C161214-9
14 -Dec -16
354 Line 8 S.
10 t
?
R01-15
Wooden Hexagon Silo
HC170116-11
C170125-17
25 -Jan -17
1012 Ridge Road E.
Page 2 of 16
a
Al
A 10
m
m
n
r
m
v
v
m
a
m
X
O
m
(n
m
O
2
(D
v
m
E
(n
m
Q-
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-16
Sir Sam Steele
HC170116-11
C170125-17
25 -Jan -17
Line 11 North. between
Memorial
Mount St. Louis Road
East and Fair Valley
Church Road
R01-17
West Oro Baptist
HC170116-11
C170125-17
25 -Jan -17
1058 Bass Lake
'
Church
Sideroad West
k
R01-18
St. Luke's Anglican
HC171120-7
C171213-10
13 -Dec -17
9160 Hwy. 12 W.
Church, Price's
Price's Corners, ON
Corners
L3V 6J8
R01-19
Stable at West oro
HC171120-7
C171213-10
13 -Dec -17
1058 Bass Lake
Baptist Church
Sideroad W., Oro-
Medonte, ON
i.-,'v
Page 3 of 16
A
Lai
ZY
0
r
m
v
v
m
0-
(D
x
O
O
h
2
(D
v
(D
E
(n
m
0
v
cD
cn
CO
0
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-20
1478 Horseshoe
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
1478 Horseshoe Valley
Valley Rd. E.
Rd. E.
r
7
R01-21
4454 Line 5 N.
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
4454 Line 5 N.
�P .: IIIvP
R01-22
Mount St. Louis
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
4784 Line 4 N.
Church
Page 4of16
A
Lai
ZY
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
0-
(D
x
0
m
m
0
h
2
cD
v
m
E
('
m
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-23
1072 Warminster
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
1072 Warminster
Sideroad
Sideroad
R01-24
Sacred Heart Church
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
1804 Warminster
Sideroad
I'I , ISM
R01-25
2379 Old Barrie Road
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
2379 Old Barrie Road
-;
E.
E.
Page 5 of 16
A
Lai
i�
0-
(D
x
0
m
('
m
0
h
2
cD
v
m
E
('
m
0
v
(D
cn
01
0
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
r
R01-26
903 Penetanguishene
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
903 Penetanguishene
Rd.
Rd.
R01-27
3270 Line 10 N.
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
3270 Line 10 N.
- r
Page 6 of 16
A
Lai
0-
(D
x
o_
m
cQ
m
0
h
2
(D
v
(D
E
(n
(D
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-28
54 Bay St.
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
54 Bay St.
•j K
R01-29
1541 Warminster
HC180226-5
C180314-7
14 -Mar -18
1541 Warminster
Sideroad
Sideroad
'
R01-30
Oro -African Episcopal
HC 180319-4
C180328-8
28 -Mar -18
11/14/2018
1645 Line 3 N.
Methodist Church
Bylaw
2018-101
Page 7 of 16
A
Al
A 10
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
a
m
X
o_
m
m
0
2
m
v
(D
r
m
0-
N
(D
v
O
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-31
Carley Community Hall
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
396 Warminster
Sideroad
R01-32
Eady Community Hall
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
73 Eady Station Road
'
R01-33
Edgar Community Hall
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
1167 Old Barrie Rd. W.
r
50
Jui
Page 8 of 16
�i
A 10
m
m
n
r
m
v
v
m
Q
(D
X
O
(D
F
(D
O
2
(D
v
(D
r
m
a
v
cD
cn
00
0
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-34
Hawkestone
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
3 Allen St.
Community Hall
l ''
R01-35
Jarratt Community Hall
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
837 Horseshoe Valley
Road E.
R01-36
1614 Ridge Rd. E.
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
1614 Ridge Rd. E.PW
A-
y
Page 9 of 16
A
Lai
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
0-
(D
x
o_
m
('
cD
0
h
2
cD
v
m
E
('
m
0
Section
#
Property
Heritage
Motion#
Council
Motion #
Date
Listed
Date
Designated
Local Address
Photos
R01-37
4191 Line 10 N.
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
4191 Line 10 N.
R01-38
276 Line 11 S.
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
276 Line 11 S.
t
Page 10 of 16
A
Lai
ZY
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
m
x
0
m
F'
m
0
h
2
cD
v
m
E
('
m
0
v
m
rn
0
0
C)
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-39
567 Line 11 S.
HC 180319-5
C180328-9
28 -Mar -18
567 Line 11 S.
a
R01-40
134 Shoreline Dr.
HC 180423-8
C180509-3
9 -May -18
134 Shoreline Dr.
y
4 �+
R01-41
1832 Ridge Rd. W.
HC 180423-8
C180509-3
9 -May -18
1832 Ridge Rd. W.
(Heard Tavern)
Page 11 of 16
A
Lai
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-42
2022 Ridge Rd. W.
HC 180423-8
C180509-3
9 -May -18
2022 Ridge Rd. W.
R01-43
8 Raikes St.
HC 180423-8
C180509-3
9 -May -18
8 Raikes St.
3 {
" mm =WON i
r
R01-44
2449 Highway 11 N
HC 180423-8
C180509-3
9 -May -18
2449 Highway 11 N.
(Ross House)
R01-45
226 Stagecoach Rd.
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
226 Stagecoach Rd.
R01-46
3985 Line 11 N.
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
3985 Line 11 N.
Page 12 of 16
A
Al
A 10
a
m
X
0
CD
(n
CD
0
2
CD
(D
E
(n
CD
Q-
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-47
4804 Line 10 N.
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
4804 Line 10 N.
a
sal i
R01-48
4302 Line 10 N.
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
4302 Line 10 N.
R01-49
133 Robinson St. (Log
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
133 Robinson St. (Log
House)
House)
• r ;
r
i
s
R01-50
2406 Bass Lake
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
2406 Bass Lake
Sideroad E.
Sideroad E.
R01-51
215 Mill St. (Yacht
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
215 Mill St.
Club
R01-52
165 Mill St.
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
165 Mill St.
Page 13 of 16
A
'al
0-
(D
x
O
m
('
m
O
2
m
v
m
E
('
m
0
v
cD
rn
CO
0
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-53
2001 15/16 Sideroad
HC 180528-5
C 180613-9
13 -Jun -18
2001 15/16 Sideroad
R01-54
3760 Line 8 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
3760 Line 8 North
z
y;
R01-55
3812 Line 8 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
3812 Line 8 North
'
R01-56
57 Mill Pond Road
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
57 Mill Pond Road
t
R01-57
2108 Ridge Road
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
2108 Ridge Road West
West
Page 14 of 16
A
Lai
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
0-
(D
x
o_
m
m
0
2
cD
v
m
E
m
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-58
2092 Ridge Road
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
2092 Ridge Road West
West
�a�.huil
R01-59
661 Penetanguishene
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
661 Penetanguishene
'
Road
Road
R01-60
1548 Line 1 South
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
1548 Line 1 South
R01-61
443 Line 12 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
443 Line 12 North
R01-62
1599 Line 13 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
1599 Line 13 North
R01-63
554 Line 15 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
554 Line 15 North
1
SIRS
R01-64
178 Line 15 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
178 Line 15 North
Page 15 of 16
A
Al
A 10
a
m
X
o_
m
m
0
2
(D
v
m
E
(n
m
Q-
v
m
rn
01
0
0
Section
Property
Heritage
Council
Date
Date
Local Address
Photos
#
Motion#
Motion #
Listed
Designated
R01-65
539 Line 15 South
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
539 Line 15 South
R01-66
53 Line 15 South
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
53 Line 15 South
R01-67
1985 Ridge Road
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
1985 Ridge Road West
West
-
R01-68
1121 Line 3 South
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
1121 Line 3 South
11'
R01-69
4715 Line 6 North
HC 180618-6
C 180718-8
18 -Jul -18
4715 Line 6 North
Page 16 of 16
A
Lai
ZY
m
m
0
r
m
v
v
m
0-
(D
x
0
m
('
cD
0
2
cD
v
m
E
('
m
0
5.c) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heri...
Appendix B
Address: _
Period:
Recorder Name:
Description:
Photographs:
Date:
Township of Oro-Medonte
Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation Form
Front Facade ❑ Left Facade ❑ Right Facade ❑
Rear Facade ❑ Details ❑ Setting ❑
Design of Physical Value
Style Is this a notable, rare or unique N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
example of a particular
architectural style or type?
Construction Is this a notable, rare, unique N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
or early example of a particular
material or method of
construction?
Design Is this a particularly attractive or N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
unique structure because of the
merits of its design,
composition, craftsmanship or
details?
Does this structure N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
demonstrate a high degree of
technical or scientific
achievement?
Notes:
Contextual Value
Continuity Does this structure contribute N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
to the continuity or character
of the street, neighbourhood
or area?
1
Page 66 of 70
5.c) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heri...
Township of Oro-Medonte Appendix B
Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation Form
Contextual Value (Continued)
Setting Is the setting or orientation of N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
the structure or landscaping
noteworthy?
Does it provide a physical, N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
historical, functional or visual
link to its surroundings?
Landmark Is this a particularly important N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
visual landmark within the:
❑ region;
❑city. or,
❑ neighbourhood?
Completeness Does this structure have N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
other original outbuildings,
notable landscaping or
external features that
complete the site?
Notes:
Integrity
Site Does the structure occupy its N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
original site?
Note: if relocated, i.e.
relocated on its original site,
moved from another site, etc.
Alterations Does this building retain most N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
of its original materials and
design features?
Is this a notable structure due N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
to sympathetic alterations that
have taken place over time?
2
Page 67 of 70
5.c) Catherine McLean, Planner re
Township of Oro-Medonte
Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation Form
Integrity (Continued)
Condition Is this building in good
condition?
Notes:
Historical or Associative Value & Significance
Does this property or structure have strong
associations with and/or contribute to the
understanding of a belief, person, activity,
organization or institution that is significant or
unique within the City?
Is the original, previous or existing use
significant?
Does this property meet the definition of a
significant built heritage resource or cultural
heritage landscape, as identified in the
Provincial Policy Statement under the Ontario
Planning Act?
A property or structure valued for the
important contribution it makes to our
understanding of the history of a place, an
event, or a person.
Names of the Original Owners:
Notes:
Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heri...
Appendix B
N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
N/A ❑ Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
Unknown ❑ No ❑ Yes ❑
Page 68 of 70
5.c) Catherine McLean, Planner re: Township of Oro-Medonte Cultural Heri...
Township of Oro-Medonte Appendix B
Cultural Heritage Resource Evaluation Form
Further Action/Follow Up
❑ Add to Heritage Register
❑ High Priority for Designation
❑ Heritage District Potential
❑ Additional Research Required
❑ Additional Photographs Required Setting ❑ All Facades ❑ Details ❑
❑ Request Permission to Access Property
Other:
General Comments
Date of Property Owner Notification:
Property Owner Name and Address:
❑ Additional Information Attached
Recommendation
Heritage Committee Recommendation
❑ Add to Heritage Register
❑ No Action — Keep on File
Date:
Council Decision
❑ Add to Heritage Register
❑ No Action — Keep on File
Date:
Notice of Collection: Information on this form is collected for the purposes authorized
under the Municipal Act 2001, s. 8; in addition to heritage preservation, information
will be used to enhance municipal services being delivered to applicants or as the
applicant my require. All information is subject to the provisions of the Municipal
Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, R.S.O. 1990, c M56. Questions
about this notice of collection should be directed to the Clerk's office at 705-487-2171
Revised June 2019
Page 69 of 70
M
5.d) Mayor H.S. Hughes; Councillor Keane re: 200th Anniversary Celebrati...
Verbal Matters
(Section 13.3 of Township's
Towushzpo Procedural By -Law No. 2017-165)
Proud Heritage, Exciting Future
Name: Councillor Keane
Item Number/Name: 5d) 200th Anniversary Celebrations
Meeting Date: I June 17, 2019
Motion No.: I HC190617-9
Type of Meeting: ❑ Council ❑ Special Council
❑ Development Services Committee
❑ Accessibility Advisory Committee
X❑ Heritage Committee
❑ Human Resources Committee
• Continuing to meet
• Nothing firm at this point
Page 70 of 70